Before You Solve the Problem, Do These Four Things
Why jumping to a solution usually creates a second problem
Let's start with a problem most couples will recognize.
One partner says: "You get upset every time I go out with my friends."
That is the problem on the table. So the other partner does what seems like the generous thing. They offer a solution. Fine, I'll stop going out with my friends. Then you'll be happy.
It sounds like a fix. It is not. All it does is create another problem.
Now one person has given up something that matters to them, which builds quiet resentment. The other person got the outcome they asked for and still feels awful, because nothing about being hurt was ever addressed. Neither of you actually understands what just happened. And the next time this comes up, and it will, you are both starting from a worse place than you did the first time.
I see this constantly. Not because people are careless with each other, but because most of us were taught that caring means fixing. A problem appears, so you solve it. That instinct is useful when your car breaks down. It fails badly when the thing in front of you is a person's feelings.
There are steps that come before the solution. Four of them. And here is the part most people do not expect: once you have worked through all four, you often find you do not need to go to problem solving at all.
Step One: Lead With Empathy
Empathy is not agreement, and it is not an apology. It is the simple act of communicating that you can see your partner is hurt.
Back to our example. It sounds like this:
"I can see that you're really hurt by me going out with my friends all the time."
That is it. That is the whole step.
Notice what is missing. There is no defence. No "but I only go out twice a week." No explanation of why the friendships matter. No solution. Just the observation that your partner is in pain and you have noticed.
This feels like it is not enough. It feels passive, like you are standing there doing nothing when you could be helping. But being seen is not nothing. For most people it is the thing they were looking for the whole time.
Step Two: Validate
Validation goes a step further than empathy. Here you are communicating the reasons why you think your partner feels the way they do.
Give two or three. It sounds like this:
"I can see that you're hurt by me going out with my friends because this is happening two or three times a week. And because I think you probably feel left out. And really, what you're wanting is to spend more time with me."
Two or three reasons, offered from their side of the situation. Not your reasons for going out. Theirs for being hurt.
This is the step people skip most often, and I understand why. Naming your partner's reasons out loud can feel like admitting you were wrong. It is not. You have not conceded anything. You have not agreed to change your plans. All you have done is prove that you actually understand what is going on for them.
There is one word that undoes this step, and it is "but." Validation followed by "but" is not validation. It is a defence with a soft opening, and your partner will hear the defence.
Step Three: Communicate Connection
This is where you offer repair.
"I'm really sorry that you're feeling those feelings. And I do want to spend more time with you. So I want to come up with a plan that works for us both, so that you feel really secure in our relationship."
Notice that this is still not a solution. There is no schedule, no compromise, no rule about Thursday nights. It is a commitment to figure it out together, which is a very different thing from one person handing down an answer.
The phrase to pay attention to is "works for us both." A solution that only works for one of you is not a solution. It is a debt, and it comes due later.
Step Four: Stop Talking
This is the one almost everybody gets wrong.
You have led with empathy. You have validated. You have offered repair. Your instinct now is to keep going. To explain your side. To make sure they understand that you were not trying to hurt them, that your friendships matter, that you have been feeling disconnected too.
Do not.
This is not where you give your reasons or defend yourself. Stop talking, and let your partner sit in the experience of being heard and understood.
Your side matters. It genuinely does, and there is a conversation where it belongs. This is not that conversation. If you add it here, everything you just did gets undone, because the last thing your partner heard was the defence.
Silence is uncomfortable. Most of us fill it. Learning not to is a skill, and it is one of the hardest ones in this whole process.
The Thread Running Through All Four
There is one thing that has to be present through every step, or none of them will hold. Curiosity.
Curiosity is what lets you get through this without defensiveness taking over. When you are genuinely curious about what is happening for your partner, you are not building your rebuttal while they talk. You are not deciding what they meant before they finish saying it. You are actually finding out.
It is nearly impossible to be defensive and curious at the same time. They cancel each other out. That is what makes curiosity so useful in the exact moment the negative cycle wants to start. I wrote more about this in The Heart of Curiosity, if you want to go deeper on that one skill.
Why This Works When a Solution Does Not
Look again at the original problem. A partner is upset about nights out with friends.
The surface problem is scheduling. The real problem is almost never scheduling. Underneath it is a question, and the question is usually some version of: do I matter to you? Will you choose me? Am I safe with you?
A solution answers the surface problem. Four steps of empathy, validation, connection, and curiosity answer the real one. That is why couples so often find the original issue has quietly shrunk by the time they get to the end. The nights out were never the point.
And if a practical arrangement is still needed, you are now making it together, from a place where you both feel understood, instead of one person surrendering something to make the discomfort stop.
Where to Start
Do not try to run all four steps in the middle of your next argument. That is like attempting a heavy lift the first time you walk into a gym.
Start with step one. The next time your partner is upset with you, before you explain anything, say one sentence naming what you can see they are feeling. Then notice what happens in the room.
That single sentence changes more conversations than most people would believe.
Want the actual words?
The free Relationship Skills Workbook walks through five skills, including empathy, validation, curiosity, and STOP, with scripts you can use in the moments when a conversation starts to escalate. It is free, and you can start using the first skill tonight.
If you want to build these into something you can reach for automatically, even when you are flooded, that is what the Relationship Super Powers course is built for. Five modules, lifetime access.
Melisha Franks is a Registered Psychologist who helps couples stop fighting against each other and start fighting for each other.
Comments